Rechercher dans le site
fontsizeup fontsizedown

Award MT Mokhtar Kadiri 1928-1989 : Section H2,5-3#

dimanche 13 février 2011
par Michal Dragoun
popularité : 2%

- MAROC ECHECS
- Février 2011
- Award MT Mokhtar Kadiri 1928-1989
- Section : H2,5-3#
- Par Michal Dragoun ,
- Praha 29 January 2011.

First, I would like to thank Abdelaziz Onkoud for inviting me to judge this tourney and for his perfect organization. Shortly after closing date I received 38 anonymized entries. Their quality was average. Before the award itself here are few notes to some problems, which I for various reasons did not honour.

PDF - 109.5 ko

Award MT Mokhtar Kadiri : section h2,5-3 .

- 1 : Kh5/Kf5 (4+15) Motivation and timing of moves interfering white battery lines are not homogenous.
- 2 : Kh8/Ka5 (2+9) Only Forsberg twins without any other unifying element are too small for award.
- 7 : Kg8/Ké4 (8+8) Use of known arrangement of two black pins is not very satisfactory. Captures of pinned pieces have different motivation and the whole aim of three black moves is one squareblock.
- 8 : Kb7/Kd6 (5+5) White moves cycle using Bishop and two pawns. I did not find concrete anticipation, but this problem has nothing more in comparison to dozens of other cycles.
- 19 : Kg1/Ké5 (5+8)At first sight I expected captures of three white pieces, but this presentation is disappointing. They are realized in different moments of the single solutions and there is no other homogenity.
- 21 : Kh8/Kd5 (5+14) Rich problem, but completely anticipated by PDB P0576550. (See A)
- 28 : Kf1/Ké4 (5+15) Heavy position with place exchange of black pieces and white unpinning switchbacks, but with apparent symmetry.
- 30 : Ka8/Ké4 (4+2) Nice echo mates, but at the cost of one black pawn more even three were realised (C. Lago, 2nd Prize E. Manolas 60 JT 2010). (See B)
- 31 : Ka1/Ré4 (4+13) 2x2 mates from both ends of the same line. Whole problem reminds me quite strongly on composition PDB P1073779 and I cannot excuse repetition of Bf7. (See C)
- 32 : Kh4/ Kd7 (4+7) Problem PDB P1107192 is very close. (See D)
- 33 : Kc5/Kh5 (4+11)White switchbacks with blocks of black King´s initial square and white transient pin. Moves of white King on pinline are more spectacular in comparison with PDB P0576774, (See E) but for me not original enough. (Without checks in the first black move can be compared e. g. with more profound PDB P0576653.) (See F)
- 35 : Ké7/Ré4 (4+5) Good example, how can be improved economy of another problem, but PDB P0506676 is the anticipation. (See G)
- 37:Kh4/Ré4 (4+8) In the solution has white King tempo move, which lacks in try. But quite close (with two tempo moves by white line pieces) is PDB P1004853. (See H)

And now awarded problems – my ranking is as follows :

Participants :

Stefan MILEWSKI (1,6),Kenneth SOLJA (2) , Christer JONSSON (2) ,Cheslav YAKUBOVSKY (3,15),Maryan KERHUEL (4),Lkhundevin TOGOOKHUU (5) ,Christopher J.A. JONES (7,14),Anatoly SKRIPNIK (8),Kenan VELIHANOV (9,11,12) ,Valery BARSUKOV (10),Araz ALMAMMADOV (13),,Abdelaziz ONKOUD (16,17),Zoltán LABAI (18,20) ,Mikhaïl GERSHINSKY (19,24),Herbert HELM (21), (22) ,Miroslav SVITEK (23) ,Alexandre PANKRATIEV (24,28,Borislav GADJANSKI (25),Bernard DELOBEL (26,27) ,Radomir NIKITOVIC (29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36),Mihajlo MILANOVIC (37),Alexandre NIKOLICHEV (38).

Pays :

Pologne ,Finlande,Suède, Biélorussie, France,Mongolie,Grande-Bretagne, Russie,Azerbaïdjan,Maroc,Hongrie et Serbie.


25-Borislav GADJANSKI
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
1st Prize
h‡3
2 solutions

- 1.Rç3 Ta1 2.T3d4 Ta4 3.Fd6 F×d4‡
- 1.Rd5 Fd8 2.Fd4 Fb6 3.Tç3 T×d4‡

1st Prize : 25-Borislav GADJANSKI.

Familiar pattern of two black pins is interpreted in new way (at least I hope) : After black King´s move the change of pin on his initial square follows and unpinned black piece interferes another one in perfect geometry of lines b2-e5 and d7-d3. White pieces must improve their position for guard of fourth rank or square c5 and – of course – their function exchange is present.


14-Christopher J.A. JONES
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
2nd Prize
h‡3
2 solutions

- 1.Tg2 T×d3+ 2.Cd4 f4 3.Fç5 F×g2‡
- 1.Fd2 F×f3+ 2.Fé4 Rb5 3.T×é5 T×d2‡

2nd Prize : 14-Christopher J.A. JONES Exchange of pinned pieces on existing pinlines. Naturally is involved function exchange between white pinning and black pinned pieces and, as a fine touch, between Bb4 and Rg5 too (unpin-block).


16-Abdelaziz ONKOUD
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
1st Honourable Mention
h‡3
2 solutions

- 1.Td7 C×é3 2.R×é3 g6+ 3.Rd4 C×é6‡
- 1.Fd7 C×é4 2.R×é4 ç5+ 3.Rf5 Cé7‡

1st Honourable Mention : 16-Abdelaziz ONKOUD Reciprocal function exchange of two pairs of white officers includes Zilahi theme in play of both Knights and passive and “active” guard by wR and wB. I noticed slight unbalance in white Knights’ moves (Sxe4 makes square c5 free and prepares opening of the fourth rank), but I forgive it.


24-A.PANKRATIEV & M.GERSHINSKY
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
2nd Honourable Mention
h‡3
b)Rf5->e5

- a)1.f×é5 Th6 2.Tg6 h3 3.Tg5 Tf6‡
- b)1.f5 F×h4 2.Fg5 b×ç4 3.Ff4 Ff6‡

2nd Honourable Mention : 24-Alexandre PANKRATIEV & Mikhaïl GERSHINSKY

Bristol manoeuvre with switchback of white pieces to intersection square vacated in the first move by black pawn.


10-Valery BARSUKOV
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
1st Commendation
h‡3
4 solutions

- 1.Tb5 Td1+ 2.Rç5 Td7 3.Rç6 T×ç7‡
- 1.Cd7 Fg1+ 2.Ré5 F×b6 3.Rd6 F×ç7‡
- 1.Dç8 T×ç8 2.Tb5 Fç7 3.Rç5 Fé5‡
- 1.Db8 F×b8 2.Ff6 Tç7 3.Ré5 Tç4‡

1st Commendation : 10-Valery BARSUKOV

Solutions with battery creation after short bQ Bristol manoevre are very well known. The second pair with “bypass” of white pieces is not very deep, but nice addition. Repetition of thematic white and black moves (Rc7, Bc7 and Kc5, Ke5 respectively) is natural, but I dislike twice used move Rb5 – without this flaw I would rank this problem higher.


17-Abdelaziz ONKOUD
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
2nd Commendation
h‡3
2 solutions

- 1.Ré4 T×d5 (1…F×d6 ?) 2.Cç5 F×d6 3.Tf4 T×é5‡
- 1.Rf6 F×d6 (1…T×d5 ?) 2.Cç7 T×d5 3.Ff5 F×é5‡

2nd Commendation : 17-Abdelaziz ONKOUD White halfpin is used for simultaneous interference of two black lines (pin on c file and one of b5-e5 or b8-e5). Unfortunately, white play is not very interesting and consists only in step-by-step captures for mate on e5.


34-Radomir NIKITOVIC
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
3rd Commendation
h‡3
2 solutions

- 1.ç×b3 Fç3 2.Fç1 Fa1 3.Td2 Cé3‡
- 1.ç3 Fç1 2.Td1 Fa3 3.Fd2 Cd4‡

3rd Commendation : 34-Radomir NIKITOVIC Good analogy in line play (moves of wB from the intersection square, black critical move, interference and mates from vacated square) is introduced by blocking moves of one black pawn. Light position and model mates, but without interesting white play. Different interpretation of similar basic pattern shows PDB P1104662, but of course it is another problem. (See I)


4-Maryan KERHUEL
MT Mokhtar Kadiri
Maroc Echecs 2011
4th Commendation
h‡2,5
b)Pc7->g7 , c)Pc7->g5 , d)pc6->f4

Solutions :

- a)1…Rç4 2.Ré6 Rb4+ 3.Rd6 Rb5‡
- b)1…d5 2.Rf7 d6+ 3.Rf8 d7‡
- c)1…Fd5 2.Rf5 Fé4+ 3.Rf4 Fd6‡
- d)1…Fé7+ 2.Rg6 Fg5 3.Rh5 Ff7‡

4th Commendation:4-Maryan KERHUEL Attempt for two pairs of solutions. First two positions with change of batteries by moves of their front piece are much more interesting. King´s cross creates connecting element of all four solutions – after 3.Kh6 in D it would be long cross, but on the other hand there is function exchange of both white Bishops in C and D.




Commentaires

Brèves

9 janvier 2010 - An Unsolved Mathematical Chess Problem

This video presents a checkmate in 24 moves puzzle along with an answer as well as a (...)

Navigation